Should Andrew Thomas have played? Should anybody play? If the medical staff clears them, they play. But maybe we only hear about the mistakes when guys get re-injured, whereas the majority of time the medical decisions work out well.Д®d says: Ronald, I think the chatter that вЂњthe Giants rushed Kadarius Toney backвЂќ or вЂњDaniel Jones shouldnвЂ™t have played last weekвЂќ is a bunch of nonsense.

But do you think there is unwise pressure to get players, or this particular player, back on the field, without considering long-term health for the good of the individual and the team? It seems to happen so often in sports. Ronald Buchheim asks: Do you think the Giants rushed Toney back despite his ankle injury? I know the answer seems obvious in hindsight. You want to kill the guy for giving Kelvin Benjamin a chance? CвЂ™mon. You can whine about Jonathan Stewart if you want, but that was so long ago now itвЂ™s pointless. Price is still on his rookie contract and heвЂ™s doing a decent job in a difficult situation. Ross, Shelton and Wilson are all low-cost, low-risk one-year signings. When the Giants signed him they were desperate for tackle help, and he was the best one on the market. The Nate Solder signing has been slammed for years and he hasnвЂ™t been worth the money, but perspective is important. Who are the first-round busts getting вЂњoutrageous money?вЂќ I do believe the AdoreeвЂ™ Jackson signing was a regrettable overpay. Saquon Barkley, Evan Engram, AdoreeвЂ™ Jackson, Daniel Jones, Dexter Lawrence, Jabrill Peppers, Billy Price, John Ross, Danny Shelton, Nate Solder, Kadarius Toney, Leonard Williams, Andrew Thomas, Isiaiah Wilson (practice squad). Here are the first-round picks on the GiantsвЂ™ roster: The Carolina Panthers have 11 if you count Christian McCaffrey and Jaycee Horn (IR) and Stephon Gilmore, technically still on PUP.

ThatвЂ™s not a crazy number, though I didnвЂ™t go and count first-round picks on every team. When will he learn that these guys are free for a reason and to stop paying outrageous money for first round busts?Д®d says: Dave, there are 14 first-round picks on the Giants roster, unless my math is off (and IвЂ™m bad at math). He has tried on numerous occasions to reactivate many of their careers and has failed. Is that on the players to do their jobs better? Is it on Graham to put players in better positions to succeed? It is probably both.Дave Kamens asks: How many first-round draft picks are on the Giants roster? Seems like Gettleman is enamored by this designation. Logan Ryan, Xavier McKinney, Lorenzo Carter, Jabrill Peppers and AdoreeвЂ™ Jackson are all playing well below expectations. Now, was last year a fluke? I wouldnвЂ™t say that, but Leonard Williams and James Bradberry did have career years. The way things have gone for the Giants this season, IвЂ™m sure his stock has dropped. I do seriously doubt that you will see GrahamвЂ™s name bandied about much in speculation about 2022 head-coaching candidates. Has the play of the Giants defense, to this point, eliminated his name from those circles and potentially a job next year with the Giants? Was last year a fluke with several players having career years or this the fluke year?Д®d says: Matt, as good as the GiantsвЂ™ defense was last season, as bright as Graham is, and as much he cares, I think it would be a massive overreaction for the Giants to out Graham from the defensive coordinator job at the end of the season if he doesnвЂ™t get things turned around. Matt Totaro asks: Last year, Patrick GrahamвЂ™s name was getting tossed around as a possible head coaching candidate before removing his name from consideration. So, letвЂ™s open up the Big Blue View Mailbag and answer some questions. New York Giants fans have a lot on their minds these days.

Fallout 4 free or kill lorenzo